[业界] 黑金！GameSpot一资深编辑因游戏评分过低 惨遭“和谐”

bt12345678

A9论坛!

http://www.primotechnology.com/2007/11/29/gamespots-gerstmann-fired-allegedly-over-kane-and-lynch-review/

最近坊间传出一则小道消息，称GamesSpot的资深游戏评测编辑Jeff Gerstmann被公司解雇，只因他有关《凯恩与林奇》的评分让发行商Eidos颇为不快，威胁要撤除在该站刊登的所有广告。
Jeff的评分确实比业内平均分略低，他为该作打了6分，位居GS的“尚可（Fair）”行列。
但有人指出Jeff的去职不仅仅是因为该作的评分问题，他还炮制过一大堆难以自圆其说的评测文章，比如他给了《托尼·霍克滑板》10分，任天堂的当家大作《塞尔达传说：黎明公主》却只得了8.8分，有相当一部分游戏Fans对其抱有敌视态度，均欲除之而后快。
目前GS及其母公司CNet尚未对此发表回应。


After publishing a critical review of Eidos’ new shooter, Kane and Lynch: Dead Men, long-time Gamespot reviewer Jeff Gerstmann today finds himself without a job.
According to a fellow Gamespot contributor and close friend of Gerstmann who wished to remain anonymous, the editor was fired Wednesday morning because of his negative review of the game, which he awarded a 6.0. Comparably speaking, Metacritic lists Kane and Lynch as currently having a 68% average from critics. I recently reviewed the game, bestowing it with a score of 3.5 out of 5 stars.
Eidos is heavily advertising Kane and Lynch on Gamespot this week, including interactive Flash banners.
The latest Penny-Arcade comic features a brief overview of this controversy. However, because the comic isn’t scheduled to ‘go live’ until tomorrow, commentary from neither Gabe nor Tycho is yet provided.
Gerstmann had been with Gamespot since 1996 and was largely responsible for its growth. Several past reviews of his have been controversial, including an 8.8 awarded to Twilight Princess and a 10.0 for Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 3.
It is possible that other factors contributed to Gerstmann dismissal in addition to the review, although this is completely unsubstantiated at the present. While we stand behind the information presented here and our source, no official announcement has been made by Gerstmann or Gamespot. Expect more details to emerge online in the next 24 hours.

呵呵,黑金时代了!

司马亮

Eidos除了古墓和盟军外还剩啥？怕他做甚

dtheiji

评分太低了
这个评分员个人偏好较严重，不给面子
被金主给修理了

草薙素子

从来无视那些什么评测……我觉的武装炼金挺好玩，要让他们来评估计都没分了……

312312321

一个评分有必要这么认真么= =每个人的观点肯定是不一样的

latch

这就是找大公司麻烦的下场。
评分是一定会有偏好的。

月夜精灵

好长时间没有看过电软了,主要是没什么游戏玩

gundamxx5903

应该允许编辑有个人喜好的存在吧。

晦月

我觉得只要言之有物...我还是喜欢看看一些人的评论的....
说是黑金事件...
在使命召唤4上大家怎么就那么异口同声啊...所以真正的大作是不会随随便便就给埋没了的...至于个人比较偏好的小作品...那就得找个跟自己爱好相近的小编的评论来看了

pf67

评分？那种东西只能用于论坛战罢了，要想真正了解游戏素质还是要看玩后感。

lxg1986163

果然很河蟹...
评分只是参考,自己觉得好玩才好

mali2006

恩, 我是从来都不看评分的说
只玩自己想玩的

一木

汗~~~~~原来国外也有黄健翔解说门事件啊 很好 很强大........

blueworld86

真是的。编辑就应该给读者一个导向，如果连这点都做不好的话就只能被和谐了。。。

东东2世

搞这些评论有什么意义啊，只要有爱就有玩的乐趣